Culture
November 19, 2026
I’ve just finished Strangers, Belle Burden’s account of the sudden collapse of her 20-year marriage. It is compelling and engaging. It is also quite brave.
But as a family lawyer, I’ve been almost as interested in the reaction to it as in the book itself.
Burden has attracted criticism on two fronts. First, that publishing such a personal account of her marriage breakdown is damaging to her children. Second, that her considerable inherited wealth undermines her account of the financial vulnerability she experienced during her divorce.
Both criticisms trouble me.
The children as a reason for silence.
The suggestion that Burden should not have published her book because of the impact on her children is a familiar one to family lawyers.
Of course, children must be protected from parental conflict. They should not be drawn into adult disputes or encouraged to take sides. But there is a world of difference between protecting children and using them as a reason to silence a parent.
The latter is a particularly effective argument because it turns the parent who speaks into the apparent wrongdoer.
What struck me about Strangers was that Burden does not seek to undermine her former husband’s relationship with their children. She describes the circumstances of his departure and the practical realities of family life afterwards, but she does not mount an attack on his parenting or suggest that the children should reject him.
She tells her own story.
That story may be uncomfortable for her former husband. It may also be difficult for their children to read. But discomfort does not, of itself, make publication irresponsible.
Burden waited until her youngest child was an adult before publishing. She clearly gave thought to the consequences.
There is something deeply troubling about the proposition that one parent can behave in a particular way, but the other must remain silent about that behaviour because describing it might affect the children’s view of the first parent.
We need to distinguish between the conduct and the telling of it.
Otherwise, concern for children risks becoming a convenient means of controlling the narrative.
Marriage is not a game of financial catch-up.
The second criticism is, from a family lawyer’s perspective, even more interesting.
A New Yorker investigation into Burden’s financial circumstances has challenged her portrayal of financial vulnerability. It revealed her considerable inherited wealth, the protection afforded by her prenuptial agreement and the substantial provision she ultimately received on divorce.
There are legitimate questions about how Burden presented her financial position. She was, and remains, an extraordinarily wealthy woman.
But I think the criticism misses a fundamental distinction.
Protecting inherited wealth is entirely different from sharing wealth accumulated during a marriage.
Burden entered her marriage with substantial family money. Her husband had considerably less. Their prenuptial agreement protected their separate wealth, including earnings accumulated during the marriage.
Burden subsequently gave up her legal career to raise their three children and manage family life. Her husband continued working and accumulated considerable wealth through his career in finance.
The suggestion that his retention of those earnings was somehow justified because she already had inherited wealth misunderstands the nature of marriage.
Marriage is not a game of financial catch-up, in which the spouse who starts with less is entitled to build a separate fortune until the financial positions are equalised.
Marriage is a partnership.
One spouse may earn the money while the other provides the childcare, stability and domestic support that enables that career to flourish. Their contributions may be different, but they are equally valuable.
And that principle does not change because the spouse looking after the children happens to be wealthy.
English family law recognises this distinction. Wealth brought into a marriage or inherited from family may properly be treated differently from wealth generated through the parties’ joint endeavours during the marriage. It also recognises that the homemaker’s contribution is no less valuable than the breadwinner’s.
That does not resolve the legal position under New York law or invalidate the parties’ agreement. But it challenges the assumption that Burden’s inheritance somehow made her husband’s earnings exclusively his.
Her existing wealth did not diminish the value of her contribution to their marriage.
The right to tell an uncomfortable truth.
After nearly 30 years practising family law, I know that two people can experience the same marriage, and its breakdown, in profoundly different ways. Both can be entirely convinced of their own account.
Burden’s former husband will undoubtedly have a different story to tell.
But that does not mean she should be prevented from telling hers.
We can question aspects of her financial narrative without dismissing the principles of matrimonial partnership. And we can recognise the importance of protecting children without assuming that a parent’s obligation to them requires permanent silence.
I found Strangers compelling, not because I necessarily accept every interpretation Burden places on events, but because she has had the courage to describe an intensely painful experience in her own words.
She is entitled to do that.
And perhaps we should be a little more interested in what she has to say than in finding reasons why she shouldn’t have said it.